10 Best Shallot Substitutes


As we all know vegetables are a perfectly delicious and healthy option to be part of our daily eating habits. And since there are many veggies that are used as part of our cooking or added fresh in salads, you can never go wrong if you add more.

Shallot onions are often found as part of many recipes and cuisines all over the world. As we all know there are many types, but shallots are somewhat unique on their own. They are part of the allium family like garlic and onions.

Soft with a taste between garlic and onion, shallots are very good to be eaten raw or added to your dish. They have a bulb with a firm texture which is good for cooking. However, if you don’t have any in your fridge or simply you want to use an alternative is there another way?

Take a look at our list and find out more about the perfect option for your cooking recipe.

Substitutes for Shallots

Vegetables can often be replaced in your cooking. Whether you are making salads, garnishing your dishes, or as part of your meal, there are many reasons why you would like to avoid using some of them or simply you have none. The same goes for shallots.

They can also be replaced by the next vegetables which are healthy, nutritious with many benefits and what is morse important they are easily found.

1. Onions

White Onion

The first replacement that we would reach out for when there are no shallots is onions. There are many types and many colors, but red and white are very commonly found as part of our veggie shelf in the fridge. They are good to be eaten raw and added to salads.

You should know that red onions are a bit spicier than shallots so don’t add too much to your cooking. Further, the taste of the white onions is considered to be even closer to shallots so you have the option to choose. They have many similarities and when you make the swap use a ratio of 1:1. 

2. Ramps


Ramps are often confused with scallions or leeks, which are neither, but wild leeks which can serve as a good replacement for shallots in cooking. They are smaller and more delicate.

They have a strong taste when they are used raw. However, once they are cooked the taste gets milder. You can add them in salads, pesto, sauces, with eggs or garnish other meals with it. Use the white bulbs and green leaves as they’ll provide a nice touch and smell to your meals.

3. Scallions


Scallions and green onions are often confused, but the difference is in the age and when they are harvested. They are also known as spring onions. Their mild taste and flavor are what make them similar to shallots and a good substitute.

Since they can be eaten raw, they are perfect for salads and some other uncooked recipes that call for shallots. If you want to get as close to the taste of shallots, use just the white base of the scallions. Replace in other cooking recipes like stews, soups, and many more.

4. Leeks


A commonly used veggie that is healthy and nutritious is leeks. Typically found in many households, they can serve as a good replacement for shallots in your cooking. They are a bit more delicate than shallots but the garlicky flavor is what makes them very similar to shallots.

When you are making the swap, use a ratio of 1:1, so 1 leek for 1 cup of chopped shallots. They can be added to pasta, with eggs, risotto, soups, and many more dishes. 

5. Pearl onions

pearl onions

Smaller than regular onions with a pearly shape, the pearl onions are a good replacement for shallots in many recipes. They are sweeter and often used for garnishing cocktails.

Both veggies have the size in common, so they can be used as a substitute for each other. They have white flesh and thin layers of rings which are firm and contain a lot of juices. Add them to recipes that call for shallots, roasts, stews, salads, and many more.

6. Garlic

Shallots have a gracious taste. And what better to replace that taste than with garlic. It is a common ingredient in our kitchen, so you can use it as a substitute at any time.

The natural taste of garlic that is in between garlic and onion closely resembles the flavors of shallots. It is often utilized as a flavoring agent in various foods especially in salad dressings, marinades, sauces, soups, or even stews.

7. Yellow onion

Yellow Onion

Another type of onion that resembles shallots is yellow. It is similar to shallots and has a very similar taste. The nice balanced taste of sweetness and bitterness makes the yellow onions unique. You shouldn’t use 1 yellow onion for 1 shallot since shallots are smaller than onions and you’ll need more in your cooking. 

8. Green onion

Green onions

Green onions are another perfect way to substitute shallots in your kitchen. Since they can be eaten raw as well as cooked, the taste which they have is very similar to shallots.

They resemble each other but keep in mind that you should just use the white part of the scallions in your cooking when making the swap. The taste of shallots may be a bit stronger, but you can always adjust based on your taste.   

9. Chives


Chives are small, fat grassy veggies that are a perfect way to replace shallots. They can be used as a substitute since they have a mid-flavor and garlicky taste just like the shallots.

They are perfect for soups, stews, mashed, omelets, and even seafood dishes. If you want to increase the taste, just slice them into even smaller pieces and add them to your cooking.

10. Cipollini Onions


Cipolla is another word for onion in Italian. This type of onion is tiny and serves as a good replacement for shallots in your cooking. They have a strong onion taste which is very similar to shallots and makes them a good substitute for each other.

They can be tender, tangy, and have traces of both sweet and sour taste. Add them to most of the recipes that call for shallots. Use in pizza, pasta, or as a side dish as well.  

Related Questions

Can I substitute garlic for shallots?

Sure you can. Shallots are actually said to be a cross of onions and garlic. You can also use them interchangeably in your meals. Either as bulbs or cloves like garlic, both options are good. 

How many onions for 2 shallots?

For replacing 2 shallots, you can use a small onion. If you need to replace more shallots, then try to find a bigger-sized onion. Use in baking or frying and add a perfect aroma to your meal.

Are shallots closer to onions or garlic?

Shallots are part of the allium family and it is closely related to both onions and garlic. When shallots are diced or sliced they are soft like the onion and provide sharp hints of garlic. So shallots are a mixture of the two.

Are shallots and onions interchangeable?

Yes, they both can be used as a substitute for each other. Use half of the number of shallots for onions. The flavors are practically the same. Therefore, you won’t notice much difference.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like