Top 3 Sweet Pickle Relish Substitutes

Sweet Pickle Relish

The sweet pickle relish is very tasty and sweet which goes really well with hamburgers or hot dogs, as well as with potato salads. It is described as a “nuclear” green relish that is very unique.

It is a very popular ingredient among children as well since it has a very mild tartness. This actually gives a different form of pickles. Especially in the U.S. the word relish usually consists of vinegar, salt, and sugar. But, what if you want to add some changes, is there a way to substitute the sweet pickle relish?

Can I substitute pickle relish? Yes. There are a few alternatives that won’t disappoint you and actually make it all work out as is supposed to be with the pickle relish. The list contains Dill, Dill pickles, and capres. Actually, there are a few others that might do the trick and make it tasty and delicious.

Find out the best recipe on how you can make your own sweet pickle relish, as well as inform yourself what are the alternatives for the famous thousand island dressing. This article will provide you with all the information that you need. All you have to do is go down and make a choice.

Substitutes for Sweet Pickle Relish

You can always use some other alternatives for sweet pickle relish. These are the alternatives that will fit well if you want to add some difference in the taste of your meal. Read the list to help you to add diversity and take your pick:

1. Dill


This is an annual herb that comes from the family Apiaceae. It is an ingredient that wieldy grows in Eurasia and it is something that is used to add additional spice to the food. It gives a flavorful taste. It is a common substitute for sweet pickle relish.

2. Dill pickles

Dill pickles

The crisp, tangy, and refreshing ingredient that has a very specific and addictive garlic dill flavor. They are a good way to add in sandwiches, veggie burgers and if you add them in your recipe you won’t regret it. Substitute for sweet pickle relish and you’ll get an incredible relish.

3. Capers


A very Immature, unripe, and green colored flower that is cultivated in Italy, Morocco, and Spain. A very good substitute that is used in many Mediterranean cuisines as well. It is widely enjoyed and will make a very good alternative.

Other Alternatives:

You can always add chopped olives, other green vegetables like bell pepper, celery, or any other freshly picked herbs. Additionally, you can add fruit or some sweet marmalade that it can work. All it actually depends on your taste.

How to Make Sweet Pickle Relish

It does not take a lot of your time and you can always prepare your own sweet pickle relish. All it takes is 20 mines to prepare it, 25 mines to cook, and all in all it’ll take up to 2 hours and 45 mines to get everything done and ready.

Follow the instructions correctly, so the final result will be a delicious and very well prepared sweet pickle relish.

All you need for this recipe are these ingredients:

  • 4 cups of chopped cucumbers
  • 2 cups of chopped onions
  • 2 cups of chopped sweet peppers ( red or yellow you choose)
  • 3 ½ cups of sugar
  • ¼ salt
  • 2 cups of cider vinegar
  • 1 tablespoon of celery seed


  • First, place the chopped cucumber into a food processor until they are all finely done and chopped. Measure and place them in a large bowl.
  • Add the sweet pepper, the seeds into the food processor and also pulse until they are finely chopped. Measure 2 cups and add to the cucumbers.
  • Add a salad and stir until everything comes all together. Cover this with ice water and set it aside for 2 hours to come to itself.
  • After this, you can rinse and drain thoroughly and also squeeze out the additional liquid if there is some left.
  • Add the sugar, vinegar, the celery seed, and mustard seed into a large pot and boil them. Stir in the vegetables and simmer for an additional 10 minutes.
  • Top the liquids and hand tight. Put in jars and process for 15 minutes.
  • You can put the jars aside to cool off completely.

Related questions:

Sweet pickle relish substitute in thousand island dressing

This is a thousand island dressing that is commonly known among people because it is also one of the “secret ingredients” to a Big Mac. As previously mentioned, the recipe for sweet pickle relish made at home includes pickles as one of the main ingredients. I have gathered you alternatives that can be added to the recipe.

Actually, in the recipe, there can be some changes, and instead of pickle relish, you can use: dill pickle relish, chopped up pickles. Actually, you can also add some variations like hot sauce, chili sauce, or horseradish. Or simply add 1 chopped hard-boiled egg, which will fit perfectly in your dressing.

Is sweet pickle relish the same as sweet relish?

They are both sweet-tasting relishes. And they also have a very fine texture. Both pickle relish and sweet relish are very commonly used with hot dogs and hamburgers. The only difference is in the pickles, which gives an additional taste.

What is sweet pickle relish made of?

The sweet pickle relish is made from cucumber, sugar, online, mustard, salad, celery seed, and cider vinegar. It is a very good ingredient to be added to fast food because it adds an additional delicious flavor.

Is relish just chopped pickles?

Actually, when making a relish, it is usually made from chopped vegetables. It is actually specified as pickle relish, meaning chopped up, seasoned pickles which add an incredible taste to your dish. Further, a relish does not necessarily require pickles. You can add any other vegetables and make them good and tasty.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like